TL;DR
Get home appliances delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Apple and Amazon have launched new smart displays that a Verge reporter says could work as shared household computers for calendars, smart-home controls and daily planning. The assessment is based on brief hands-on time, so their performance and usefulness in homes remain untested; the devices also differ in price and reliance on phones.
Apple’s $299 HomeView and Amazon’s $499.99 Echo Show 16 have arrived with stronger hardware and household-focused software, leading a Verge reporter to say they could make smart displays useful as shared family screens. The report is based on brief hands-on time, not extended testing, so whether the devices deliver on that role in everyday use remains uncertain.
The devices are positioned for household tasks such as checking a shared calendar, managing meal plans, controlling connected lights and checking who is at the door. The Verge report describes this as a different aim from using a conventional computer for homework or paying bills: the screen would serve as a central, always-available place for routine family information and controls.
The report says Apple’s HomeView uses an A18 chip and Liquid Retina display, while Amazon’s Echo Show 16 has a MediaTek processor and the Nanomatte display also used in Amazon’s new Alexa Tablet. The reporter argues that more capable hardware could address a longstanding weakness of smart displays, but the report does not provide comparative performance tests.
The products take different approaches to shared use. The Echo Show 16 is presented as a household device that can be set up without a phone, though Amazon says a phone can help. HomeView is more closely tied to the iPhone: it offers built-in apps, while other functions rely on a connected phone. The report says some of its more personal features depend on recognizing a user and having that person’s phone nearby.
Many household routines—calendars, shopping lists, meal planning and smart-home controls—are managed through personal phones. A fixed screen that multiple people can access could make that information easier to share and reduce dependence on one person’s device. The Verge report points to demand for communal screens, including the popularity of products such as the Skylight Calendar.
The price is a central consideration. The report compares the new devices with older, lower-cost displays: the Echo Show 5 cost $85 in 2023, and Google’s Nest Hub cost $99. HomeView starts at $299, while the Echo Show 16 costs $499.99. The newer products therefore make a more expensive pitch, and their value will depend on whether their household features work reliably enough to justify the cost.
They also raise a practical choice for buyers: whether a shared screen should adapt to individual users or operate mainly as a device for the home. Apple’s phone-linked model may offer more personal context, while Amazon’s approach is designed to function across a household without requiring each task to begin on an iPhone.
Products Worth Considering
TCL T7 Series 85-Inch 4K 144Hz QLED Smart Google TV
TCL QM64L 85-Inch QD-Mini LED 4K Smart Fire TV
Sony BRAVIA 5 85-Inch Mini LED 4K HDR Smart TV (K-85XR50)
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Smart Speaker to Home Hub
Three years before this report, the Verge writer described smart displays as a struggling category, saying earlier devices from Google and Amazon had limited hardware and tried to serve too many purposes. The writer had argued that future models needed better performance, easier shared access and an interface available without repeated setup steps.
The report also discusses Google’s Pixel Tablet, a tablet designed to work as a smart display when docked. The writer said its detachable screen was a problem at home and its smart-home support was incomplete. Google reportedly canceled a successor about 18 months later. A tablet can offer a large screen, but the writer identifies multiuser support and portability—meaning the device can be moved away and its battery depleted—as drawbacks for a permanent family hub.
The new Apple and Amazon models are presented as attempts to address those issues with always-available screens and household features. That framing comes from the reporter’s early impressions; it does not establish that the products will resolve the category’s usability problems.
“These could finally turn the smart display into what it should have been all along: the family computer.”
— The Verge reporter
Early Impressions, Not Home Tests
The report does not establish how well either display performs after extended use, how reliably household members can switch between accounts, or whether the interfaces remain easy to use for everyone in a home. The reporter explicitly says proper testing is still needed.
Details of the two products’ full capabilities and limitations are also not established in the supplied report. In particular, the extent to which HomeView’s features work without a nearby iPhone, how Amazon’s household features handle different users, and how the devices compare in daily use remain open questions. The report describes demonstrations and product characteristics, not independent verification of every feature.
It is also not clear whether the higher prices will make either product worthwhile for households that already use a tablet, a lower-cost smart display or a dedicated calendar screen. No sales figures or consumer response data are included.
Extended Testing Will Settle the Case
The next meaningful step is longer-term testing of both devices in real households. That can show whether their calendars, meal-planning tools, smart-home controls and camera features are accessible to multiple people, and whether the screens are useful enough to stay in a shared space.
Readers considering a purchase can compare the devices’ phone requirements and household functions against the tasks they actually want a shared screen to handle. The supplied report does not provide a later review, broad availability information or a timeline for further testing, so those details remain pending.
Key Questions
What are the HomeView and Echo Show 16?
They are smart displays from Apple and Amazon, respectively. The report presents them as screens for shared household tasks such as calendars, meal planning and smart-home controls.
How much do the two displays cost?
The report gives a price of $299 for Apple’s HomeView and $499.99 for Amazon’s Echo Show 16.
Do both devices require a phone?
According to the report, the Echo Show 16 can be set up without a phone, although one may help. HomeView is more closely connected to the iPhone, and some features rely on a recognized user and a nearby phone.
Have the devices been fully tested?
No. The Verge account is based on brief hands-on time. Its reporter says extended testing is needed to determine how well the devices work in everyday household use.
Are they replacements for a family computer?
The report uses “family computer” to mean a shared screen for household information and controls, not a device for homework or paying bills. It does not present either display as a replacement for a conventional computer.
Source: theverge.com
